The Sandstorm: Class Size Matters…Not A Whit - For Kids And Country
close

For Kids & Country

  • Home
  • Join The Movement
  • About
  • Adopt A Teacher
  • Blogs
  • News
  • Resources
  • School Options
  • SeXXX Education
  • Toolkits
  • Union Exit
  • Union Politics
  • Videos
  • Donate
  •  Facebook
  •  Instagram
  •  Pinterest
  •  Twitter
  •  YouTube
For Kids & CountryFor Kids & Country
  • Menu
  • Join The Movement
      • Join The Movement
      • START HERE
      • Interactive Map Of Grassroots Groups Across America
      • Share A Printable Handout
  • Adopt A Teacher
  • Union Exit
      • Step One:

      • Teacher Toolkit
        • FAQ’s About Leaving Unions
      • Step Two:

      • Union Opt-Out
        • Opt Out of Your Union Today – By State (All 50 States)
      • Step Three:

      • Liability Insurance
        • Christian Educators Association International
        • Association Of American Educators
      • Extra Information You Might Want To Know

      • Keep Your Local
        • How To “Keep Your Local” Only Association
        • Union Facts: How To Decertify
        • CA Independent Teachers
        • Non-Union Alternatives For You
  • Union Politics
      • Union Politics
        • Union Politics (Home)
        • The Gompers’ Saga
        • Shocking Videos Of Union Leaders
  • School Options
  • SeXXX Ed
      • SeXXX Education
      • SeXXX Education (Home Page)
      • Parental Non-Consent Form for SeXXX Ed
      • California Parent Opt-Out Notice For SeXXX Ed
      • Get Educated About SeXXX Ed Toolkit
      • FKC Talks Sex Ed w/ PragerU
      • Helpful Organizations
        • The Legacy Institute
        • Alliance To Protect Children
        • Faith & Public Policy
        • Family Watch International
        • Parents’ Rights In Education
        • Protect Our Kids Now
        • Sex Ed Report
        • Stop CSE
        • United Parents
  • Toolkits
      • Toolkits
        • Critical Race Theory Toolkit
        • Parent Advocate Toolkit
        • Get Educated About SeXXX Ed Toolkit
        • Union Opt-Out Teacher’s Toolkits
  • News
      • In The News
        • News
        • Editorials In The News
          • By Rebecca Friedrichs
          • By Marguerite Gaspar
          • By Larry Sand
        • Interviews With FKC
        • Shocking Statements By Teachers’ Union Leaders – In Their Own Words
      • Blogs
        • Delighting In Safe Pasture With Linda
        • From The Teacher Shepherd
        • The Gompers Saga
        • Inspiring Stories
        • Lessons By Educators We Trust
        • Rebecca’s Musings: Thoughts Of Hope And Faith
        • The Sandstorm
      • Videos
        • FKC Talks Teacher Freedom With PragerU
        • FKC Video Archive
  • About
      • About FKC
        • About For Kids And Country
        • Founder’s Message
        • Join The Movement
        • Our Mission
        • Stay Connected
        • Privacy Policy
      • Rebecca Friedrichs
        • Meet Our Founder
        • Rebecca’s Book
        • Standing Up To Goliath
          • Book Club Questions
          • Book Reviews
      • Helpful Organizations
        • CA Teachers Empowerment Network
        • Gateways To Better Education
        • MN Educated Teachers
        • PA Free To Teach
        • Union Facts
  • Donate

The Sandstorm: Class Size Matters…Not A Whit

By Ted Stelle,

November 27, 2018
Title: Class Size Matters…Not A Whit
Author: Larry Sand
Date: November 27, 2018

Perhaps the “fake news” story of the year – actually the last 20 years – is that small class size is essential to learning.

Under the leadership of its cantankerous president Alex Caputo-Pearl, the United Teachers of Los Angeles is planning to strike – very possibly in January. The union’s demands haven’t budged, even as the Los Angeles Unified School District has made concessions. But unlike the union, LAUSD is constrained by fiscal realities, and has county and state auditors waiting to pounce if it missteps.

Other than portraying LAUSD chief Austin Beutner as “an out-of-touch millionaire” on a regular basis, the union’s main order of business – not surprisingly – is a salary increase for its teachers. But close behind in the demand department is the class size issue. The union is calling for an across-the-board chop, while the district is offering to reduce class size in 90 “high-need” schools. According to the latest data, the pupil-to-teacher ratio in Los Angeles is 19.7, not exactly an unreasonable number. (Nationally, in 1955 the ratio of teachers to students in public schools was 26.9 to one. In 2018, it is down to 14.5 to one, according to the U.S. Department of Education’s National Center for Education Statistics.)

So the union is trying to get the district to spend money it doesn’t have to fix a non-existent problem.

As a former teacher, I know that a small class makes life easier – fewer papers to grade and parents to have to deal with, for example. That said, there is no evidence that it makes a whit of difference in student learning. I and others have been writing about this for years, but old myths die hard. Now we have a new meta-analysis – results from multiple studies – which again shows that small class size is a red herring. The report, produced by the Danish Centre of Applied Social Science, examined 127 studies, eliminating many that did not meet strict research requirements, and finds that there may be tiny benefits to small classes for some students when it comes to reading. But in math, it found no benefits at all and the researchers “cannot rule out the possibility that small classes may be counterproductive for some students.”

So 127 studies later, it’s basically a wash. The Danish analysis did nothing more than underscore Hoover Institution economist Eric Hanushek’s results of his review of class-size studies in 1998. Examining 277 separate studies on the effect of teacher-pupil ratios and class-size averages on student achievement, he reported that 15 percent of the studies found an improvement in achievement, while 72 percent found no effect at all and 13 percent found that reducing class size had a negative effect on achievement. While Hanushek admits that in some cases, children might benefit from a small-class environment, there is no way “to describe a priori situations where reduced class size will be beneficial.”

Additionally, EdChoice researcher and economics professor Benjamin Scafidi found that between 1950 and 2015, the number of teachers increased about 2.5 times as fast as the uptick in students. He adds that despite the staffing surge, students’ academic achievement has stagnated or even fallen over the past several decades.

And the hiring uptick is not limited to teachers. As the late Cato Institute scholar Andrew Coulson wrote in 2012, public school employment doubled in 40 years, while student enrollment increased by only 8.5 percent – about an 11-to-1 ratio – and academic results stagnated. Coulson writes that teachers and aides accounted for about two-thirds of the hiring increase. The remaining hires were a mix of often needless support personnel, notably administrators, counselors, social workers, reading, curriculum specialists, etc. Coulson explains that if we returned to the student-to-staff ratio of 1970, “American taxpayers would save about $210 billion annually in personnel costs.”

When the true believers push for smaller class size, the unintended consequences are rarely acknowledged. Despite what many union leaders would have us believe, money is a finite entity and is wasted on mandated small classes. When class size is reduced, schools have to spend more to hire teachers. Districts are frequently forced to add portable classrooms or even build new schools to accommodate the small classes. Additionally, increased hiring dilutes the pool of qualified teachers.

So what do smaller class sizes actually accomplish?

For the unions, an increase in the teaching staff means more dues money and clout.

For the already overburdened taxpayer, less money.

For the children? Absolutely nothing.

Post navigation

← PreviousCalifornia Political Review: The Delightfully, Annoyingly Persistent Rebecca Friedrichs
NextAaron Benner →

 

Recent News

  • Delighting In Safe Pasture With Linda: The Roaring Lion And The Wizard Of Oz
  • The Sandstorm: Randi, Get A Grip!

Follow Us

Facebook

For Kids & Country

2 days ago

For Kids & Country
They want woke ideologies to take over our kids' education. So why does Rebecca Friedrichs call them "So-called" Teachers' Unions? Watch and find out... ... See MoreSee Less

Nikole Hannah-Jones, others advocate for critical race theory in wake of Buffalo shooting

www.foxnews.com

Progressive voices ramped up calls to add critical race theory to school curricula following Saturday's shooting in Buffalo, N.Y.
View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

For Kids & Country

4 days ago

For Kids & Country
Time to Adopt A Teacher today and help us rescue our schools by subverting the power of so-called teacher unions. ... See MoreSee Less

Join The Movement - For Kids And Country

www.forkidsandcountry.org

Our Mission is to Unite, Educate, Engage and Empower Parents, Teachers, Students, and Citizens in the fight to restore America’s schools and culture.
View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

Purchase Standing Up To Goliath

Stay Informed

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Optional Information Below To Be Included.

Our Mission

Our Mission is to Unite, Educate, Engage and Empower Parents, Teachers, Students, and Citizens in the fight to restore America’s schools and culture.

Contact

For Kids & Country
P.O. Box 75032
San Clemente, CA 92673
[email protected]

Media Inquiries

For Interviews Please Contact:

The KAIROS Company
[email protected]

Follow Us

You can make an impact while you shop for Black Friday deals. Simply shop at smile.amazon.com/ch/83-0822116 and AmazonSmile will donate to For Kids & Country Inc, at no cost to you.

© For Kids & Country· 2018-2022 · All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy